HOMEMADE SWEETS. ALL-STAR FLAVOR
Classic homemade treats with a little baseball-inspired twist. From drop cookies and custom sugar cookies to cakes and desserts for life’s special moments, everything is made with care and quality ingredients.
Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, hosting a team party, planning a special event, or simply craving something sweet, we’re ready to step up to the plate.
Made from scratch. Made to celebrate. Made to be remembered
Cookies
Big, soft, bakery-style cookies packaged with flavor. Choose from our signature lineup of baseball-inspired favorites, seasonal specials, and classic combinations.
Custom Sugar Cookies
Hand-decorated royal icing cookies created especially for your celebration. Perfect for birthdays, showers, graduations, sports events, weddings, holidays, and more.
Cakes
Custom cakes made to look just as good as they taste, with a variety of cake flavors, buttercreams, and fillings available to create the perfect combination.
MADE FOR YOUR BIG MOMENTS
Birthdays. Graduations. Baby Showers. Team celebrations. Holidays. Weddings. Just because.
Whatever you’re celebrating. The Batters Box Bake Shop can create something sweet that feels completely yours.
Custom orders are designed around your event, colors, theme, and vision so your desserts become part of the celebration-not just something on the dessert table.
FROM OUR HOME PLATE TO YOURS
The Batters Box Bake Shop is a home-based bakery on Long Island, New York, specializing in handcrafted cookies, custom desserts, and celebration cakes.
every order is made in small batches with the same goal: to create desserts that bring people together and make special occasions even sweeter.
Batters Box Merch
Rep The Batters Box wherever you go.
Our apparel is printed to order and shipped directly to you.
